The Great Gatsby: The Psyche of Society
Psychoanalysis has most often gotten its methods and
analogies from language. Vocabulary has played a vital role in helping us to
understand our inner most thoughts and desires. Meaning can be derived from
many different types of expression, but there is a form of language that can speak
about what our desires are in an extremely potent way. This would be the
language of representation.
A
representation, as defined by Henrik Encknell,” is an instrument through which
something points to something else”. In Baz Lerman’s, The Great Gatsby, there
are multiple representations, thoughts, and images that speak of the
unconscious and latent desires that are evident in both the director himself,
and the author of the novel that this movie is based on, F. Scott Fitzgerald.
It is also a representative of the psyche of society as a whole.
The film is a dream, a manifestation of the unconscious,
where we see latent desires slip out and we can understand what the conveyors
of this story are trying to say about the world and society that we are living
in. In this dream state, both men are represented in the form of Nick Caraway,
the young, impressionable protagonist. He would be the direct manifestation of
their conscious, the character that is torn between the pull of the ID, Ego and
Super Ego, represented by Tom, Daisy and the one and only Gatsby. The film itself would be representative
of the society that we live in and what will happen if we continue on the way
the characters of this story do.
This film is set in the time period that is most
representative of our own. The time period of the 1920’s was a time when money
was abundant, where alcohol was cheep, and the morals were loser then they had
ever been. The energy of the city of New York at the time was palpable, the
music louder and the parties bigger. This time in history is most similar to
the decade that we are living in right now. These the manifestations of the
inner struggle of Lerman are based in a society that is so similar to our own
that it creates for an interesting look at the reasons why he is showing these
desires and thoughts through this film and this story.
The film starts out with a black and white screen, an
echo of days gone by. In this intro we get the impression that we are entering
a memory or a dream. The black and white morphs into color, intense and vivid
images flash on screen as a classical movie score turns into Jay-z and Beyonce
hip hop, during which characters move quickly trying to make sense of the
turbulent and tumultuous world around them.
Each character is a manifestation of the psyche of
the creators of this story. Tom Buchanan
would be the manifestation of the ID of Lerman and Fitzgerald. The Id is the part
of our unconscious that holds our most carnal and primeval desires. Tom is
representative of this as the character that is driven by basic drives, such as
food, games, and sexual pleasure. The ID of Lerman is obviously rife with the
need for his primeval desires to be met because of the way these things are
represented through Tom. When we first see Tom’s mistress, Myrtle, the only
image on screen, when she first talks, is solely of her chest. Her face isn’t
shown at all when we first hear her she is speaking. For Tom, the ID, the only
things he notices are the objects of his desires, the beautiful woman that he
can get with without any thought for the feelings of his wife or the other
people around him, and without noticing that she is a human being, rather then
an object. He is solely focused on getting what he wants and what he feels he
deserves.
For
Lerman and Fitzgerald, their Id is largely in control for the beginning of the
story. Their lives were driven by their Id, Fitzgerald was an alcoholic himself
and the in the world that Lerman is a part of in Hollywood is largely driven by
the carnal desires of the people living there. The ID of society would tell us
that there are no consequences, but Lerman is letting us know through these
this character that everything we do has an effect attached to it. That no
matter what society would tell us about “a little party never killed nobody,”
in reality, a little party could have a larger consequence that cannot be seen
until it is to late.
And this
is where Daisy, the ego of Lerman and Fitzgerald, comes in. The Ego is the part
of the unconscious that tries to please the id’s desires in a realistic way. It
is the balance between primitive desires and reality. Daisy is the character
that is the most torn, the character that tries to placate the Id, both her own
personal desires and her husband, Tom. Daisy, meditates between Gatsby, the
super ego, and Tom, the Id. She knows Tom is cheating on her but she loved him
once, and knows it is morally wrong to be with Gatsby. She says at one point that
it would have been better to have been born stupid and pretty rather then
having a brain that understands that moral and social implications of her
actions. She is majorly conflicted by following what she would want to do,
which is be with Gatsby. But why is she conflicted? She has no problem sleeping
with Gatsby at first, but as soon as he commands her to say she never loved
Tom, she freaks out, backs off and retreats inside herself.
Daisy is losing her hope for life and for society.
She says that all precious things fade and they don’t come back. As Daisy is
representing the part of the unconscious that is there to try to placate the id
and live in reality, Lerman is telling us that the things that allow our
society to function in such a way that we can placate the Id, or have
consequences for the fulfillment of primitive desires at the expense of others,
are starting to diminish and that we are starting to lose hope on having a
system that is ruled by the ego rather then the Id.
Mr. Jay Gatsby is described when we first meet him as
the most hopeful person Nick Caraway has ever met. He describes Gatsby as
having the sensitivity of a machine that can register an earthquake hundreds of
miles away. Gatsby is the super-ego of this manifestation of the unconscious.
The Super ego is the part of the unconscious that plays the critical and
moralizing role. It tries to influence the ego the same way the Id does. The
super-ego is manifest in Gatsby in the way that he is the representation of
what should have been. He was a poor young man, who worked hard to become a
gentleman and be worthy of Daisy’s love and affection. He is the character that
does his best to undo the mistakes that have been made in his life and in
society.
The battle for control that these three characters
have is the battle that is playing inside of our society right now. Each
character is a representation of different thoughts of society. There are those
who would say eat drink and be merry for tomorrow we die, and then there are
those who fight for a more moral society, and lastly the group caught in the
middle, the ones who are most impressionable, trying to decide which lifestyle
to choose. Lerman is showing us that there are consequences of living in a
society that is torn by the want to have carnal desires met, and the desire for
justice and order.